Two modes of the human mind

As understanding of human intelligence develops it is becoming clear that within the ebb and flow of everyday life, the brain-mind can shift between two basic modes of operation. One of these I refer to as goal-directed activity (GDA), which is about motivated cognition and behaviour to follow a sequence of behaviour toward an intended goal. The other is about states of mind involving reflection, awareness, and creativity. I will explain the differences below, but let’s start with GDA.
GDA involves multiple parts of the brain, but the prefrontal cortex (PFC) plays a crucial ‘executive’ role to maintain focused attention and coordinate the required behaviours. During the process, the brain is constantly anticipating what is going to happen next, based on prior learning, and adjusting behaviour based on feedback from the environment.
For most people, the GDA mode will be ‘on’ for significant parts of every day, as we leave the home environment to get things done out in the world. GDA is naturally suited to thinking about and being at work, travelling here and there, making plans, assigning tasks, attending meetings, going shopping, writing emails, and on it goes. Typically, such activities occur within (or relate to) relatively complex social environments, beyond one’s small network of close relationships.
During these times, the brain will not only be focused on pursuing goals but also on monitoring other people’s behaviour to anticipate any possible problems and adjust accordingly. When these social cues come along, short-term stress arousal kicks in to assist rapid adjustments. Complex social environments are always stress-inducing to some extent, because they involve a degree of uncertainty about how other people will behave.
While the operation of GDA states in complex social environments is important, useful and sometimes rewarding – a part of wellbeing – it is also tiring, even if things are going well. If life is a struggle and social relationships feel conflicted, the associated stress demand will likely be higher, increasing fatigue and undermining mental health. GDA states can also be habit forming. A person’s mind may continue to ‘work’ problems and challenges even during their ‘down time’. Digital media exacerbates this problem.
The other mode
There is a family of mental states available to us which reduce rather than stimulate stress, and promote experiences of calm, rest, connection, happiness, and meaning. They can be considered together as a second basic mode of brain-mind activity because of four common features: they all involve reduced activity in relevant areas of the prefrontal cortex, and reduced stress arousal, and benefits for mental health, and all tend to occur in settings outside of complex social environments. This combination of features is not a coincidence.
In Western cultures we tend to see time away from purposeful action out ‘in the world’ as just passive periods of rest and recovery, before we re-engage in the real business of life. During those times, many people turn to alcohol, drugs, junk food, gambling or social media to seek temporary relief from the psychological demands of GDA, but with little real benefit and, in fact some lasting harms. These behaviours are everywhere while, at the same time, relatively few people fully grasp their own potential to think, feel, experience, and be human in other ways, which benefit and enrich life.
Three forms of brain-mind activity share the four common features noted above. All provide real relief from the demands of GDA and complex social environments, but more importantly they open up a range of restful, rewarding and potentially profound experiences.
Social relatedness: This is about spending relaxed time interacting with close, trusted others; talking, sharing food, playing games, and so on. Relatedly, it is also about having a secure sense of being supported and valued by close others, even when one is not actively interacting with them.
Absorbed practice of a skill: This is about absorbed engagement in exercising a skill of some kind, alone or with others, just for the pleasure of doing so. It might be art or craft activities, reading, gardening, or doing a jigsaw. Some refer to these as ‘flow’ states.
Present-moment awareness: This is about practices of ‘letting go’ attention on tasks, problems or responsibilities and ‘just’ paying attention to the here and now. This might be done through a mindfulness practice, contact with the natural world, or just relaxing with a cup of tea and looking out the window.
I cannot emphasise enough that these are not just pleasant, fleeting interludes away from the ‘real’ business of solving problems, getting stuff done, making money, influencing others. Together these three ways of being constitute another dimension of human experience; one that is essential to wellbeing and a pathway to meaning and fulfilment. For the purposes of this article, I will describe them provisionally as forms of connected awareness activity (CAA).
Other evidence for the distinction
So, we have a description of two distinct modes of operation in the brain-mind and related experience: GDA which is goal-focused, aroused, anticipatory, and problem solving, and CAA which is more relaxed, connection-focused, immediate and exploratory. We know that GDA is characterised by strong PFC arousal for executive control, while in CAA states the arousal of the PFC is reduced and brain activity shifts into other patterns. Are these distinctions consistent with other evidence? I think they are.
Current research describes a ‘default mode network’ (DMN) pattern of activity the brain shifts into when goal-directed or socially engaged mental states are disengaged. A primary feature of this process in the brain is reduction of activity in the PFC. The three states I describe are not the DMN, but they share this crucial feature.
The distinction between GDA and CAA as two basic modes of operation is consistent with the binary difference in function between the sympathetic and parasympathetic nervous systems. The former drives multiple processes of bodily arousal during episodes of stress and intense activity to deal with challenges. The latter control processes of body relaxation and recovery during periods of calm and safety.
The GDA-CAA distinction is also consistent with definitions in psychology of two basic forms of motivated behaviour; extrinsically motivated activity to earn an external reward or avoid a negative consequence, and intrinsically motivated activity to do something that is inherently interesting or enjoyable. As we would expect, extrinsically motivated activity is associated with elevated stress arousal.
Wider implications
If this distinction between GDA and CAA holds true as something basic to human social intelligence and behaviour, what implications might follow for our societies and politics? For one thing, based on my work in philosophy, I would say that description of the GDA mode fits well with concepts of ‘reason’ and ‘self-determination’ in political philosophy; two concepts which in turn underpin liberal political theory, which has done so much to shape contemporary Western capitalist societies.
In more practical terms, the structures and values of modern, capitalist societies – without knowing it – elevate GDA through social values like ‘focus’, ‘ambition’, ‘hard work’, or material ‘success’. We suppose mistakenly that the good life will follow from embracing these values. In fact, I would suggest, these same values have led to societal structures and norms that maintain people in aroused GDA states over extended periods of time, making them more vulnerable to fatigue and stress. Meanwhile, the harmful activities people turn to for temporary relief, such as alcohol use, are treated as opportunities for commercial exploitation. The harms can easily extend into people’s social relationships, undermining an essential source of wellbeing. If CAA is recognised at all, it is only as forms of niche activity or mildly pleasant relaxation in between bouts of GDA.
The profound problem here is not with GDA as such, it is with social structure and values that: a) elevate GDA to a dominant social value; b) drive people to engage in GDA over extended periods of time exposing them to risks of chronic stress; c) exploit people’s subsequent fatigue with potentially addictive forms of relief seeking; and d) obscure the nature and value of CAA as part of a fulfilled and balanced human life.
What would society be like, how would our values change, how would we organise our lives if goal-directed activity and connected awareness activity were treated as two equally important parts of a balanced life?



